![]() |
Publication overview - Contents - Top/Bottom - Previous/Next | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
The Activity in the Danish Money Market |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Kim Abildgren, Economics and Henrik Arnt, Payment Systems Introduction and summary
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Average daily turnover of day-to-day loans on the money market in the 4th quarter of 2003 and the 1st quarter of 2004 |
Chart 1
|
![]() |
|
| Note: Average turnover in krone-denominated day-to-day loans per banking day.
Foreign-exchange swaps and repos are based on daily reporting from 13 banks in Denmark. Besides the figures reported by the 13 banks, deposits are also based on payments via Danmarks Nationalbank's payment system Kronos. The turnover comprises the overnight (o/n) and tomorrow-next (t/n) segment for deposits, the turnover in the t/n and the spot-next (s/n) segment for repos and the turnover in the t/n segment for foreign-exchange swaps. |
|
| Source: Danmarks Nationalbank. | |
|
Loan types in the danish money market
|
Box 1
|
|
Deposits are uncollateralised krone-denominated loans with standardised maturities from 1 day up to 12 months. Repurchase agreements (repos) are collateralised krone-denominated loans with standardised maturities from 1 day up to 6 months. The pledged collateral comprises securities, typically bonds. Repos are also known as sell and buy-back transactions since on the conclusion of the agreement the seller of the bonds (the liquidity recipient) enters into an obligation to buy back the securities at a later date at a price fixed when the agreement is entered into. The repo rate is reflected in the difference between the agreed purchase and sales prices (spot and forward prices). Foreign-exchange swaps (FX swaps) are collateralised krone-denominated loans with standardised maturities from 1 day up to 12 months. In this case the collateral is foreign exchange, typically dollars. A foreign-exchange swap can be seen as a simultaneous spot and forward foreign-exchange contract: when the spot transaction is settled, kroner are exchange for foreign exchange, and vice versa when the forward contract is settled. The rate of interest on the krone-denominated loan is reflected in the spot and forward exchange rates applied. |
|
On average, the total turnover of uncollateralised day-to-day loans in the Danish money market was kr. 18.6 billion per banking day in the period from the 4th quarter of 2003 to the 1st quarter of 2004. One half was traded between Danish and foreign market participants, while the other half was traded among Danish banks and mortgage-credit institutes, i.e. Danmarks Nationalbank's monetary-policy counterparties. The latter part of the turnover is described in the following sections.
A well-functioning money market is important for e.g. ensuring a clear transmission from Danmarks Nationalbank's monetary-policy interest rates to the short-term market rates. The interest rates in the money market are the basis for the interest rates which the banks offer their customers for deposits or lending. Thus, Danmarks Nationalbank has an interest in supporting an active money market by designing the monetary-policy instruments in such a way that the counterparties exchange liquidity on market terms among themselves rather than trade exclusively with Danmarks Nationalbank.
Danmarks Nationalbank's monetary-policy counterparties comprise banks and mortgage-credit institutes. The large monetary-policy counterparties are expected to participate actively in the money market and thereby be responsible for ensuring a well-functioning marketplace with efficient price formation.
In principle, Danmarks Nationalbank only provides liquidity to the monetary-policy counterparties once a week. During the week the counterparties must normally trade among themselves on market terms via the money market, thus supporting the activity in the market.
Danmarks Nationalbank has a current-account limit, which is an overall ceiling on the monetary-policy counterparties' current-account deposits at the close of the day, i.e. at the close of the monetary-policy day at 3.30 p.m. Current-account deposits with Danmarks Nationalbank are demand deposits which the monetary-policy counterparties may use as a means of payment without notice and at their own initiative. The current-account limit thus constitutes a ceiling on the volume of day-to-day krone liquidity which the counterparties taken as one can obtain at their own initiative. The purpose of the current-account-limit system is to discourage the build-up of large current-account deposits which could be used to speculate in changes in interest and exchange rates. The total limit is approximately kr. 20 billion, broken down as individual current-account limits for the counterparties. The activity in the money market is an important factor in the allocation of individual current-account limits. It is, therefore, natural to group the monetary-policy counterparties according to their individual current-account limits in analyses of the trading volume in the money market, cf. below.
Danmarks Nationalbank regularly collects data from 13 banks on their money-market trading in deposits, repos and foreign-exchange swaps, cf. Damm and Pedersen (1997). The statistics are relatively aggregated, comprise only the lending side and do not provide for detailing the trading structure.
As regards the monetary-policy counterparties' trading among themselves in uncollateralised day-to-day loans, it is, however, possible to map the market structure in detail. The reason is that Danmarks Nationalbank is banker to the banks and mortgage-credit institutes and that the liquidity exchange between the institutions takes place via accounts with Danmarks Nationalbank via Danmarks Nationalbank's payment system, Kronos. For instance, if bank A on Monday agrees an overnight loan of kr. 100 million to bank B, the transaction in itself implies a payment of kr. 100 million from bank A's current account to bank B's current account on the same day. When the loan is repaid including interest the next day (Tuesday), an opposite payment from bank B's current account to bank A's current account of kr. 100 million plus interest is executed. On the basis of payments via Kronos it is thus possible to detail the trading volume in the uncollateralised part of the day-to-day money market. The method is described in more detail in the Appendix.
As appears from the Appendix, a compilation of the trading in uncollateralised day-to-day loans based on payments in Kronos is associated with certain factors of uncertainty. However, the overall assessment is that the compilation provides a fair picture.
| Trading volume in uncollateralised day-to-day loans among monetary-policy counterparties in the 4th quarter of 2003 and the 1st quarter of 2004 |
Table 1
|
||||
|
|
Loans per banking day
|
Deposits per banking day
|
|||
| Current-account limit (Kr. million) |
Number
of institutions |
Kr.
million |
Per
cent |
Kr.
million |
Per
cent |
| 700 and above |
6
|
6,085
|
65
|
6,240
|
67
|
| 300 699 |
7
|
1,569
|
17
|
2,080
|
22
|
| 101 299 |
20
|
1,222
|
13
|
619
|
7
|
| 50 100 |
60
|
429
|
5
|
308
|
3
|
| 1 49 |
24
|
0
|
0
|
59
|
1
|
| Total |
117
|
9,305
|
100
|
9,305
|
100
|
| Source: Danmarks Nationalbank. | |||||
Danmarks Nationalbank's monetary-policy counterparties are 117 banks and mortgage-credit institutes. Table 1 shows the institutions' trading in uncollateralised day-to-day loans in the 4th quarter of 2003 and the 1st quarter of 2004, grouped according to the institutions' current-account limits.
The average daily turnover is kr. 9.3 billion per banking day. The turnover is fairly equally distributed on the days of the week. The lowest average daily turnover occurs on Fridays (kr. 8.0 billion) when Danmarks Nationalbank is normally open for sale of certificates of deposit and collateralised monetary-policy lending. The highest average daily turnover occurs on Thursdays (kr. 11.0 billion).
The six largest institutions (i.e. the six institutions with the six highest individual current-account limits) account for around 65 per cent of the turnover, while the 13 largest institutions account for 80-90 per cent. The tendency for a large part of the turnover to be concentrated on relatively few participants is known from money markets in other countries.[5] This is predominantly a "wholesale market" where the main participants are the largest institutions. The banks and mortgage-credit institutes not actively participating in the money market instead exchange liquidity via correspondent banks and transactions directly with Danmarks Nationalbank.
As mentioned, active participation in the money market is an important factor in the allocation of individual current-account limits. This is illustrated in Table 1 where by far the largest part of the turnover is placed with the institutions with the highest current-account limits. The same trend is also seen in Table 2. On average, the six largest institutions have around 2.5 loans and 2 deposits per banking day. The smallest institutions, on the other hand, are generally not active in this part of the money market.
| Activity in the market for uncollateralised day-to-day loans among monetary-policy counterparties in the 4th quarter of 2003 and the 1st quarter of 2004 |
Table 2
|
||||||
| Current-account limit (kr. million) |
Number
of institu- tions |
Lending
|
Deposits
|
Number of
institutions that at least once in the period executed |
|||
|
Average
number of trans- actions per institution per banking day |
Average
trans- action amount (kr. million) |
Average
number of trans- actions per institution per banking day |
Average
trans- action amount (kr. million) |
Lending
trans- actions |
Deposit
trans- actions |
||
| 700 and above |
6
|
2.52
|
402
|
2.05
|
507
|
6
|
6
|
| 300 - 699 |
7
|
0.75
|
298
|
1.08
|
274
|
6
|
6
|
| 101 - 299 |
20
|
0.47
|
131
|
0.45
|
69
|
16
|
15
|
| 50 - 100 |
60
|
0.16
|
44
|
0.16
|
33
|
30
|
28
|
| 1 - 49 |
24
|
0.00
|
40
|
0.05
|
51
|
1
|
1
|
| Total |
117
|
0.34
|
236
|
0.34
|
236
|
59
|
56
|
| Source: Danmarks Nationalbank. | |||||||
The average size of a transaction between monetary-policy counterparties in the uncollateralised day-to-day market amounts to approximately kr. 400-500 million for the largest institutions and approximately kr. 30-50 million for the small institutions.
The average size of the loan transactions is described in more detail in Table 3. On average, the largest institutions with a current-account limit of minimum kr. 700 million executed 318 loans during the 4th quarter of 2003 and the 1st quarter of 2004. On average, 57 of these transactions (equivalent to 18 per cent) amounted to more than kr. 500 million while 182 of the transactions (equivalent to 57 per cent) amounted to kr. 100 million or less. The large loans of more than kr. 500 million were primarily to other large institutions while most of the small loans were to small and medium-sized institutions. In connection with the latter, it should be noted that large institutions frequently operate as the main banker to small institutions. Institutions with a current-account limit of kr. 100 million or less primarily conclude transactions of less than kr. 100 million.
| Number of lending transactions in the 4th quarter of 2003 and the 1st quarter of 2004, average per institution by loan amount and the lender's current-account limit |
Table 3
|
|||
|
Number of lending transactions:
|
||||
| Lending by institutions with a current-account limit (kr. million) of: |
Maximum
kr. 100 million |
More than
kr. 100 million and maximum kr. 500 million |
Above
kr. 500 million |
Total
|
| 700 and above |
182
|
79
|
57
|
318
|
| 300 - 699 |
42
|
36
|
17
|
95
|
| 101 - 299 |
43
|
13
|
3
|
59
|
| 50 - 100 |
19
|
1
|
0
|
20
|
| 1 - 49 |
0
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
| Note: Uncollateralised day-to-day money-market loans among monetary-policy counterparties in the 4th quarter of 2003 and the 1st quarter of 2004. Source: Danmarks Nationalbank. |
||||
Kr. 50 million is the most frequent transaction size, which accounts for approximately 8 per cent of the total number of transactions. This is followed by transaction sizes of kr. 100 million and kr. 25 million that each accounts for around 6 per cent of the total number of transactions while transaction sizes of kr. 10 million and kr. 20 million each makes up 4 per cent of the total number of transactions. However, a large number of transactions are of "odd" amounts. This shows that to a large extent the uncollateralised day-to-day money market is used to settle daily liquidity surpluses or deficits in the individual institutions.
Chart 2 shows the average total number of different trading counterparties for active institutions during the 4th quarter of 2003 and the 1st quarter of 2004. The largest institutions trade with around 25 different counterparties, while the group of medium-sized institutions on average has around 15 different counterparties.
| Number of different trading counterparties per institution during the 4th quarter of 2003 and the 1st quarter of 2004 |
Chart 2
|
![]() |
|
| Note: For each category of current-account limit the average number of counterparties is calculated based on institutions that have concluded at least one transaction in the uncollateralised day-to-day market among monetary-policy counterparties in the 4th quarter of 2003 or the 1st quarter of 2004. | |
| Source: Danmarks Nationalbank. | |
Table 4 shows the distribution by value of uncollateralised day-to-day money-market loans among the institutions per banking day in the 4th quarter of 2003 and the 1st quarter of 2004. Total lending by institutions with a current-account limit of kr. 700 million and above amounted to kr. 6.1 billion per banking day, of which kr. 4.3 billion (equivalent to 71 per cent) went to other large institutions. Correspondingly, the largest institutions received 70 per cent of their deposits from other large institutions.
Table 4 also illustrates that to a considerable degree the medium-sized banks trade liquidity among themselves. For instance, 8 per cent of the loans from institutions with a current-account limit of kr. 100-299 million were to other institutions of a similar size. On the deposit side the figure was 17 per cent. The trading pattern is thus relatively diversified, which contributes to ensuring potential competition and thus efficient price formation.
| Distribution by value of trading volume in uncollateralised day-to-day loans among monetary-policy counterparties in the 4th quarter of 2003 and the 1st quarter of 2004, average per banking day (kr. million) |
Table 4
|
|||||
|
To institutions with a current-account limit (kr. million) of:
|
||||||
| From institutions with a current-account limit (kr. million) of: |
700 and above
|
300-699
|
101-299
|
50-100
|
1-49
|
Total
|
| 700 and above |
4,340
|
1,125
|
360
|
201
|
59
|
6,085
|
| 300 - 699 |
1,243
|
228
|
71
|
28
|
-
|
1,569
|
| 101 - 299 |
421
|
661
|
103
|
38
|
-
|
1,222
|
| 50 - 100 |
236
|
66
|
86
|
41
|
-
|
429
|
| 1 - 49 |
0
|
-
|
-
|
-
|
-
|
0
|
| Total |
6,240
|
2,080
|
619
|
308
|
59
|
9,305
|
| Source: Danmarks Nationalbank. | ||||||
Damm, Birgitte and Anne Reinhold Pedersen (1997), New Money-Market Statistics, Danmarks Nationalbank, Monetary Review, 3rd Quarter.
Danmarks Nationalbank (2003), Monetary Policy in Denmark.
Danmarks Nationalbank (2004), Financial stability.
Furfine, Craig H. (1999), The Microstructure of the Federal Funds Market, Financial Markets, Institutions and Instruments, Vol. 8(5), December.
Furfine, Craig H. (2003), Interbank Exposures: Quantifying the Risk of Contagion, Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, Vol. 35(1), February.
Millard, Stephen and Marco Polenghi (2004), The relationship between the overnight interbank unsecured loan market and the CHAPS Sterling system, Bank of England Quarterly Bulletin, Spring.
Pedersen, Anders Mølgaard and Michael Sand (2002), The Danish Money Market, Danmarks Nationalbank, Monetary Review, 2nd Quarter.
Payments in kroner among the monetary-policy counterparties take place via Danmarks Nationalbank's payment system, Kronos, and are settled via accounts with Danmarks Nationalbank. Thus, trading in uncollateralised day-to-day loans among the monetary-policy counterparties may be identified by using an algorithm searching through the individual payments in Kronos. An equivalent analysis method has been used previously by others. Furfine (1999) analysed the structures in the US day-to-day money market (the federal funds market) based on data from a search algorithm with assumptions similar to those in Danmarks Nationalbank's algorithm, while Millard and Polenghi (2004) carried out a similar study of the money market in the UK. Furfine (2003) used the same method and data to estimate systemic risks in the US interbank market. Danmarks Nationalbank (2004) contains a similar analysis.
The idea of the search algorithm is simple. For instance, if bank A grants bank B an overnight loan of kr. 100 million at an annual interest rate of 2 per cent, a payment of kr. 100 million will be made from bank A's current account with Danmarks Nationalbank on the day of the agreement, while on the same day a payment of kr. 100 million will be made to bank B's current account. The loan of kr. 100 million is repaid from bank B to bank A on the following day with accrued interest of kr. 5,555.56 (= 0.02*100,000,000/360). The algorithm runs through all payments via current accounts of banks and mortgage-credit institutes and searches for repayments on the following banking day "matching" the accrued interest.
The agreed interest rate for the individual loans is not known in advance and may depend on the counterparty's credit rating, the time of transaction and liquidity in the money market in general. Thus, the algorithm searches for counterbalancing payments where the accrued interest may vary within a certain interval. This interval is determined on the basis of day-to-day interest rates that are reported daily to Danmarks Nationalbank from 13 banks. The lower limit of the interval is determined by the lowest reported interest rate for uncollateralised overnight or tomorrow-next transactions less 0.25 per cent per annum. Similarly, the upper limit of the interval is determined by the highest reported interest rate plus 0.25 per cent per annum. The interval is not constant as the difference between the lowest and the highest reported interest rate varies from day to day. The interest-rate interval is shown in Chart 3.
| Interest-rate interval in search algorithm |
Chart 3
|
![]() |
|
The reason for adding and deducting 0.25 per cent is that the reported interest rates are based on a weighted average of all trades in the relevant segment. The interest rates for the individual trades may therefore deviate from the reported average. Since the algorithm does not differentiate between overnight and tomorrow-next transactions[6], the lowest and highest, respectively, of the two reported interest rates is used as the point of departure. To avoid that other types of day-to-day transactions, cf. Box 1, than uncollateralised day-to-day loans are identified by the algorithm only payments of at least kr. 1 million and which are in whole hundred thousands (i.e. ending in five zeros) are included. A payment of kr. 2.1 million is thus included as a potential loan, while a payment of kr. 2.15 million is not. The reason for this criterion is that "round figures" are the market standard for deposit transactions. Furthermore, it ensures that foreign-exchange swaps are not included, as these are typically agreed in round amounts in dollars which predominantly result in odd amounts in kroner. Collateralised trades in the form of repos are settled by VP Securities Services and thus not via individual transactions between current accounts. Loans between institutions that are both part of the same group and that both have current accounts with Danmarks Nationalbank are disregarded.
In the 4th quarter of 2003 and the 1st quarter of 2004 approximately 323,000 payments were made in Kronos between current accounts equivalent to 2,561 payments per banking day, cf. Table 5. The algorithm identified approximately 21 per cent of these payments as candidates for uncollateralised day-to-day money-market loans, and matching repayments of around 7 per cent hereof were found.
| Identification of uncollateralised day-to-day loans |
Table 5
|
|
|
Number
|
Value
(kr. million) |
|
| Payments per day in Kronos |
2,561
|
209,331
|
| Of which potential day-to-day loans |
544
|
100,255
|
| Of which identified day-to-day loans |
39
|
9,305
|
| Note: Payments are here defined as a payment from one current account to another. Source: Danmarks Nationalbank. |
||
The loans identified by the algorithm are solely uncollateralised day-to-day loans between monetary-policy counterparties, i.e. banks or mortgage-credit institutes with interest-bearing current accounts with Danmarks Nationalbank. Consequently, only parts of the market for uncollateralised day-to-day money-market loans in kroner are included. The analysis does not comprise trading with foreign institutions and with small institutions that are not monetary-policy counterparties.
A compilation of the money-market trading volume based on payments in Kronos is associated with some factors of uncertainty. For example, the algorithm will fail to identify instances where several loans to the same counterparty on the same day are bundled into one repayment on the following banking day. Similarly, in principle the algorithm fails to identify loans between monetary-policy counterparties executed via a common correspondent bank. There may also be day-to-day money-market loans agreed at higher or lower interest rates than the interest rates defined by the algorithm. Finally, the capture of "random" items that are not attached to day-to-day money-market deposits cannot be ruled out.
Thus, the figures are associated with some uncertainty. The overall impression, however, is that the compilation provides a fair picture of the monetary-policy counterparties' trading among themselves in uncollateralised day-to-day loans in the 4th quarter of 2003 and the 1st quarter of 2004. To check the calculated trading volume on one single day, it has been compared with reports from a questionnaire survey for selected banks. This random sampling confirms that it is possible to identify uncollateralised day-to-day money-market loans via the method described.
[1] The same data was used for an analysis of systemic risks in the Danish banking and mortgage-credit sector in Danmarks Nationalbank (2004).
[2] Monetary policy in Denmark is described in detail in Danmarks Nationalbank (2003). The development in the Danish money market during recent years is described in detail in Pedersen and Sand (2002).
[3] In this article "krone liquidity" means current-account deposits with Danmarks Nationalbank. In this connection, krone liquidity may also be called "current-account liquidity" or just "liquidity".
[4] However, it should be noted that, all other things being equal, the trading volume in products at the short end of the money market is higher than the trading volume in products with longer maturities, since loans with short maturities are refinanced more frequently than loans with longer maturities.
[5] In the USA, where the banking sector comprises around 10,000 institutions money-market participation is also relatively concentrated. Only around 1,000 institutions executed day-to-day loans via the money market during the 1st quarter of 1998, and of these the 100 largest accounted for more than 85 per cent of the loans, cf. Furfine (1999).
[6] Only settlement date and time are known. The actual time of agreement is unknown.