
|
Financial Markets
Equity prices rose considerably in 2006 despite falling prices in mid-year. The tightening of monetary policy in both the USA and the euro area had only little impact on the long-term yields, so that the yield curves became flatter. At the same time, credit spreads remained historically low.
The volatility in mid-2006 shows how exposed the financial markets are to even small changes in market expectations. Large geared positions in different currencies, including carry trades, contribute to increased volatility in the market.
INTERNATIONAL FINANCIAL MARKETS AND FINANCIAL STABILITY
The financial markets are of great importance to the banking institutions' earnings and balance sheets. There is a direct impact through various channels as value adjustments of the banking institutions' bond and equity portfolios, and via fee and commission income from financial-market-related customer services. The financial markets also have an impact on the financial situation of the banking institutions' clients and financial counterparties.
In addition, the general development in the financial markets affects the banks' costs of raising capital via bond or equity issues.
EQUITY AND BOND MARKETS
Equity markets continued to rise in 2006
Global equity prices rose considerably in 2006 despite falling prices in mid-year. The European Stoxx index rose by 20 per cent, while the US S& P 500 index increased by 14 per cent, cf. Chart 27. The Danish OMXC20 index mirrored the development in the international markets closely, rising by 12 per cent in 2006. The relatively large price drops in mid-year were attributable to increasing uncertainty among investors, who moved towards assets entailing lower risk. Despite significant increases in recent years, the price-earnings ratios seem to indicate that the equity markets are not yet at the same high price levels seen before the dotcom bubble burst in 2001.
EQUITY INDICES IN DENMARK, THE EURO AREA AND THE USA, AND VOLATILITY IN THE EURO AREA, 2001-07 |
Chart 27 |

|
Note: The volatility is based on 50 option prices and measures market expectations of short-term volatility. It is calculated by taking the square root of the implied variance across all options for a given period until they mature.
Source: Ecowin. |
Expectations of the banks' earnings remained strong in 2006, so that the bank equity indices rose more than the general equity indices. The bank equity indices increased by almost 23 per cent in both the euro area and Denmark, cf. Chart 28. The increase was less pronounced in the USA, where the bank index rose by just over 12 per cent.
EQUITY INDICES FOR DANISH, EUROPEAN AND US BANKS, 2001-07 |
Chart 28 |

|
| Source: Ecowin. |
Yield curves in the USA and Europe flatten out
10-year yields rose slightly in 2006, in spite of a decrease in the 2nd half of the year, cf. Chart 29. The increase in the 1st half-year was driven by high economic activity and rising core inflation. In step with expectations of lower growth in the economy, however, the US 10-year yield fell in the 2nd half-year. The European 10-year yield followed the development in the US market.
2-YEAR AND 10-YEAR YIELDS ON BENCHMARK GOVERNMENT BONDS IN THE USA AND GERMANY, 2001-07 |
Chart 29 |

|
| Source: Ecowin. |
In general, long-term yields rose less than short-term yields, so that the yield curves flattened out in 2006. Especially in the euro area the short-term yield rose strongly as a result of sound economic growth. The European Central Bank, ECB, raised its official interest rate from 2.25 per cent to 3.75 per cent in six increments during 2006 and the start of 2007. The substantial increases in short-term interest rates in Europe and the USA, and in other countries with sound economic growth, led to increasing carry-trade speculation, cf. Box 2. The market utilised the low interest rates in countries such as Japan and Switzerland to invest in countries with relatively higher interest rates.
CARRY TRADES |
Box 2 |
The carry-trade strategy is a well-known phenomenon and essentially reflects that investors seek out assets yielding a relatively high return. In this case, an investor borrows an amount in a currency with a low interest rate (the funding currency) and invests in a currency that pays a higher interest rate (the target currency). Assuming that exchange rates are constant, the investor's profit is the interest-rate spread between the two currencies.
Exchange rates are not constant, however. The Chart below shows the interest-rate spread and the exchange-rate volatility for a number of currency pairs. The interest gain at the various crosses is clearly positive, but is subject to uncertainty in the form of exchange-rate volatility.
It is difficult to assess the actual size of carry trades since, for many investors, carry trades are effected as off-balance-sheet transactions. Some assessments of the total volume of carry trades are as high as 1,000 billion dollars.[1] Once the volume of carry trades becomes sufficiently large, the strategy becomes self-enhancing. The reason is that when large volumes of capital flow from a low-interest currency to a high-interest currency, the latter will appreciate vis-à-vis the former. This means that the gain on carry trades is equivalent to the interest-rate spread and the appreciation of the high-interest currency. For example, the total yield on sterling-yen carry trades was 19.3 per cent in 2006, but only 8.5 per cent in 2005.
A major risk factor in connection with carry trades is the threat of an exchange-rate bubble. The formation of a bubble leads to further uncertainty in addition to the historical exchange-rate volatility. When a bubble bursts, it does so very quickly, and it tends to spread. The consequences may be pronounced depreciation of various target currencies vis-à-vis funding currencies. |
INTEREST-RATE SPREADS AND HISTORICAL EXCHANGE-RATE VOLATILITY |
|
Note: 3-month LIBOR rates from 26 February 2007 have been applied. The historical exchange-rate volatility has been calculated as the annualised standard deviation for the period since 2003.
Source: Reuters and Ecowin. |
In the USA, the 2-year yield exceeded the 10-year yield throughout most of 2006. Normally, this has indicated an imminent recession in the US economy. This time, however, the low long-term yields are attributed to low and stable inflation expectations, investments by OPEC countries and Asian central banks in long-term US government bonds, and high demand for duration on the part of pension funds.
The market expects further interest-rate increases in Europe
Prices of financial assets contain information on market participants' expectations of future market developments. Future interest rates, called forward rates, can be calculated on the basis of yields on bonds with different maturities. A forward rate can be perceived as a break-even interest rate that indicates how much the spot yield curve must change if bonds with different maturities are to provide the same yield. The forward interest rate between e.g. year 1 and year 2 shows the 1-year interest rate one year ahead if an investor is to receive the same yield from purchasing either a 2-year bond – of which the yield is known today – or a 1-year bond – of which the yield is known today – followed by another 1-year bond at the forward interest rate.
The full break-even probability distribution for the future short-term European interest rate can be derived on the basis of the prices of interest-rate options. In Chart 30 it is seen that the interest rate is still expected to increase as the short-term interest rate is around 4 per cent at the end of April 2007. This reflects market confidence in the economic development and thereby expectations of a further tightening of monetary policy. The uncertainty of interest-rate expectations has also diminished from the spring of 2006, as the distribution has narrowed.
PROBABILITY DISTRIBUTIONS FOR EURIBOR DERIVED FROM OPTION PRICES |
Chart 30 |

|
Note: The risk-neutral probabilities are estimated using a combination of log-normal distributions. The calculations are made with a constant horizon/maturity of eight months.
Source: Bloomberg and own calculations. |
Credit spreads in Europe and the USA remain narrow
Ample international liquidity has significantly narrowed the credit spreads between corporate bonds in recent years, cf. Chart 31. The falling trend in the USA continued in 2006, while the spread widened slightly in the European market.
CREDIT SPREADS FOR BONDS IN THE USA AND THE EURO AREA, 2002-07 |
Chart 31 |

|
| Source: Ecowin. |
Most recently the spreads have widened a little in the USA, among other things due to increasing uncertainty concerning the economic development in the USA. Investors have sold higher-risk assets in favour of more secure government bonds. Another factor of uncertainty is related to increasing payment difficulties among less creditworthy US homeowners in the " subprime" mortgage-credit market. The bond index, which reflects the price development for the high-risk mortgage-credit bonds, thus fell by more than 30 per cent towards the end of February.
IMPLICATIONS FOR THE FINANCIAL MARKETS OF A WEAKENING US HOUSING MARKET |
Box 3 |
Following several years' strong expansion, over the last six months the US housing market has shown clear signs of a slowdown. A major factor contributing to the growth in the housing market has been an aggressive lending policy vis-à-vis less creditworthy homeowners (known as the subprime lending market). Loans to this homeowner segment are today approximately 1,000 billion dollars, and constitute approximately 12 per cent of the total portfolio of housing loans in the USA, against 7.5 per cent in 2001. The significant expansion was attributable to such factors as large volumes of liquidity seeking higher returns than the low yields on more secure assets.
As housing prices have begun to fall and short-term US interest rates have risen, the number of defaulted loans in the subprime market has risen substantially. Previously, it was easier for borrowers to refinance their loans in the expectation that housing prices would rise, and a large proportion have raised adjustable-rate loans. In the 4th quarter of 2006, defaulted subprime loans increased to almost 15 per cent of the total subprime loan portfolio. More than 20 subprime lenders have been closed or acquired by larger operators since the beginning of 2006.
The increasing nervousness in the market is reflected in large price increases to safeguard against overdue housing loans.
Mounting payment problems in the mortgage-credit market have led to fears of credit rationing in the US economy. These fears have been amplified by the spread of payment problems to more creditworthy borrowers. The banks are more hesitant to issue new housing loans, and it is feared that this will further weaken the housing market. At the same time, the risk premium on corporate bonds outside the housing sector has risen recently, and equity prices for a number of financial institutions that are exposed to the housing sector have also fallen substantially. |
[1] The Economist, 10-16 February 2007.
|
|
| Publication in PDF-format. |
| |
PC: Press the right mouse-button, choose "Save Link As", then choose where to save the file.
|
| |
| MAC: Hold down the mouse-button, choose "Save Link", then choose where to save the file. |
| |
Download
Acrobat Reader here:
 |
| |
| |
| |
|