Summary
Robust Financial Sector in Denmark
The international financial markets
have been characterised by turmoil since the summer of 2007. This is reflected
in Danish banks' financial statements for 2007. Earnings rose in the 1st half of
the year, but the 2nd half marked a turning point for many banks after a
prolonged period of earnings growth. Looking ahead, the banking sector will
continue to be affected by the financial turmoil and the less favourable
outlook for the Danish economy. Risks to financial stability have become more
pronounced recently. The banks have become more exposed in the light of their
growing lending portfolios and the reduction of their capital buffers in recent
years. The Danish financial sector is, however, deemed to be sufficiently
resilient to withstand major economic shocks.
The financial turmoil
affects Danish banks
The
current turmoil in the international financial markets stems from falling
housing prices in the USA and the rising number of defaults on mortgages by
less creditworthy homeowners, i.e. subprime borrowers.
At first, the
strong price drops were mainly observed in structured financial products
composed of subprime mortgages. However, the turmoil quickly spread to other
parts of the financial system, and the period since August 2007 has been
turbulent for both money and equity markets.
Banks in the USA
and Europe have suffered considerable losses as a result of the subprime
crisis. Consequently, several banks have tightened their credit policies.
Growth prospects have deteriorated, and especially for the US economy the
outlook is more gloomy.
The turmoil in
the international financial markets is also visible in Danish banks' financial
statements for 2007. The 1st half of 2007 saw continued earnings growth, while
the 2nd half marked a turning point for many banks after a prolonged period of
earnings growth. For the year as a whole, the banks' earnings fell by 14 per
cent on 2006.[1] The decrease
is attributable to capital losses on securities and higher write-downs on lending,
among other things.
The
banks' lending continues to increase, albeit at a diminishing pace. Higher
financing costs and the financial turmoil have dampened the banks' expansion,
and many banks have raised their lending rates in 2008.
The new capital-adequacy
rules, Basel II, together with the International Financial Reporting Standards,
IFRS, have contributed to the banks reducing their capital reserves.
Consequently, the banks have become more exposed to adverse economic scenarios.
The risk outlook
The turmoil in the international financial markets impacts the risks
faced by the banks.
Increased
volatility in the financial markets entails higher market risk and hedging
costs for the banks. In addition, the turmoil has brought the banks' liquidity
risk into focus. Some banks operate with small liquidity reserves, which
affects their scope of manoeuvre under unexpected circumstances. These banks
may be forced to raise loans in periods when market conditions are unfavourable
or to raise loans with shorter-than-required maturities in a situation where
some markets tend to disappear completely.
In the event of sustained turmoil in the international financial
markets, with continuously high credit spreads, the price of the banks'
financing via the money and capital markets may increase further. Banks with
large deposit deficits and without a good rating are particularly exposed to
interest-rate fluctuations in the money and capital markets.
In addition to
risks related to the financial markets, there are also risks associated with
the macroeconomic development. Expectations of economic growth in the USA have
been steadily reduced as a result of the weak US housing market and the
financial turmoil, and the probability of a recession in the USA has increased.
A slowdown in the US economy and the global economy overall will also affect
the Danish economy and Danish banks.
Unemployment has
decreased further in Denmark in 2007 and the beginning of 2008. The capacity
pressure is high in the Danish economy, and economic growth is expected to slow
down. Rising wages and higher commodity prices may lead to intensified pressure
on the companies' budgets, which will increase the probability of default on
loans, resulting in losses for the Danish banks.
The depreciation
of the dollar is an additional risk factor for banks with considerable lending
to companies exporting to the USA and other dollar-priced markets.
Calculations
based on Danmarks Nationalbank's failure-rate model, KIM, show higher estimated
failure rates for Danish companies in general. This can be attributed to
increased indebtedness, more companies with negative earnings, and the
establishment of many new companies in 2007. Viewed in isolation, the estimated
failure rate is higher for new companies than for well-established companies.
The higher indebtedness and estimated failure rates for the companies imply
that the banking sector's expected losses on corporate exposures have risen
from 2006 to 2007, although they continue to be low.
In 2006, the
surging housing prices made way for stagnating or falling prices, cf. Chart 1. Danish
household finances are still sound overall, despite high and increasing debt,
and unemployment is very low. There are no significant indications of the
households having difficulties in servicing their loans. A more pronounced
downturn in the housing market, with plummeting prices, is a risk factor, but
it is only found to be probable in the event of significant increases in
interest rates and unemployment.
HOUSING PRICES AND HOMES FOR SALE IN DENMARK |
Chart 1 |

|
| Source: The Danish
Association of Chartered Estate Agents, www.boligsiden.dk and the Association
of Danish Mortgage Banks. |
The Danish banking sector
is still assessed to be robust overall
The risk scenario described above is illustrated by the following three
constructed stress test scenarios:
- The
subprime crisis continues and leads to a recession in the USA: The price of interbank financing rises sharply.
The increase is partially passed on to the customers. Growth in the US economy
is negative for eight quarters.
- Increases
in commodity prices: Commodity
prices, especially oil prices, rise sharply, and official interest rates are
raised to keep inflation at bay.
- Property price drop: Interest
rates and unemployment increase, while property prices and the value of assets
pledged as collateral for bank loans decrease.
The stress test scenarios are compared with a baseline scenario that is
considered to be the most likely development in the Danish economy and the
financial sector. Calculations based on Danmarks Nationalbank's stress test
model show that all banks classified by the Danish Financial Supervisory
Authority in groups 1 and 2 will achieve a profit at almost the same level as
in 2007 if Danmarks Nationalbank's baseline scenario is realised. In the stress
test scenarios the financial result will be negative for most banks in at least
one of the three scenario years, but without leading to solvency problems, cf.
Chart 2. Only one bank will have solvency problems if exposed to the tough
economic scenarios. All in all, the results show that the Danish financial
system is resilient to the scenarios in question, but that it cannot be ruled
out that a few banks will have problems.
MACRO STRESS TEST RESULTS (NUMBER OF BANKS) |
Chart 2 |

|
Note: The banks are in random order in the two groups.
Source: Own calculations. |
A static sensitivity analysis also shows that the Danish financial
sector is robust. However, the analysis shows greater exposure to rising
financing costs and increasing losses on lending portfolios compared with
corresponding calculations based on the banks' financial statements for 2006.
The Nordic groups
have also become more exposed to both increasing losses and rising financing
costs. At the same time, the market assessment of the resilience of the Nordic
groups is on the decrease, although the resilience in most cases exceeds the
level for other European and US banks.
[1] Adjusted for Danske Bank's acquisition of Sampo Bank.
|